The One-Island Model of Migration and Water Snakes in Lake Erie

In the example on water snakes in Lake Erie that models migration, data is given about the frequency of different phenotypes. There are two mainland populations and and three island populations that we are observing. The snakes on the mainland have a much higher frequency of the striped phenotype (D), while the snakes on the island have more of a striped phenotype (B & C) or a strapless grey color (A). 

In each island, you can find low frequencies of the D phenotype proving that migration is happening between the mainland and island populations. Because of the dilution effect, you do not see phenotypes A, B, or C on the Ontario mainland. This basically means that migration from the islands to the continents has little to no affect because of the large population found on the mainlands. The migration of snakes from the mainland to the island would have the opposite effect because the small population size does not allow that phenotype to be diluted out. The amount of phenotype D found in each population can be very telling about the amount of migration happening from the mainland to the islands. The peninsular mainland is fairly close to the islands and the mainland, so it has a high frequency of D phenotype and a mix of small amounts of A, B, and C phenotypes. Kellys island is the closest one to the peninsular mainland, which is why it shows a higher frequency of the D phenotype. Because this island is closer to the mainland, it is apparent that the higher frequency is due to more migration. The Pelee and Middle islands are further from the peninsular mainland and therefore have a smaller D phenotype frequency and a higher A phenotype frequency. This could be due to Pelee island's size and its ability to support a larger population. There could also be more rocks on this island that the population had to adapt to in order to survive, making phenotype A more fit. The Bass complex islands are fairly close to the peninsular mainland and have genetic diversity, exhibiting mostly phenotypes A & B. The low frequency of D could be due to the fact that there is less of a need for that phenotype and that other phenotypes are more beneficial on those islands. The Ontario mainland is farther away from the islands, which explains why there is little to no migration from the islands to the mainland.

Because each population can encounter slightly different environments and also have mutation, selection, and genetic drift acting on each population, this can cause genetic differentiation between populations. In this case, I feel that migration can be both beneficial and harmful to the different populations. The mainland populations may be less fit on the islands and lead to detrimental effects for those population that migrated. On the other hand, this may lead to more genetic diversity and fixation of positive phenotypes.

Comments

  1. Hi, Lola! I really liked what you wrote. I especially enjoyed the last section that talked about the benefits and drawbacks of migration. However, I have a question for you: do you think that dilution effect could be the only reason that there are no A, B, or C phenotypes in Ontario? I was thinking about it, and even with dilution effect, surely you would still be able to see those phenotypes on the graph. Do you think it is possible that all of the snakes on the islands migrated from the Ohio mainland and migrated back and forth there because they could not swim the distance to and from Ontario?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Does selection eliminate genetic variation?

Comparison of Neutral Evolution and Natural Selection

Comparing Natural Selection and Evolution