Evolution According to Lamarck
Lamarck’s view of evolution had flaws, but some of the concepts align slightly with the evolution theory that most people agree with today. His idea that species change over time and that life is not fixed was not totally wrong considering the information that we know today. Lamarck’s understanding of the mechanisms at which species evolve was not completely correct, but he did hit on some basic important ideas of evolution. One of his ideas was that if the environment changed, the species had to change in order to adapt and be able to survive. We see that concept in the finches on Galapagos Island, who changed their beak size in order to get food during a drought that changed the available nutrients. His idea of change of use and disuse was along the right track, but he was wrong in the sense that they would increase in size or disappear if they were not used. Lamarck also thought that giraffes stretching their necks caused a longer neck to be acquired in the next generation. An example that disproves Lamarck’s theory about evolution is August Weismann and his experiment with cutting off the tails of mice. In his experiment, Weismann cut off tails of both sexes of mice in order to prove that this acquired trait could not be passed onto future generations of offspring (Liu, 2007). The other concept that he did not get quite right was that species go through changes that only cause them to become more complex and move them upward. This is not correct because evolutionary changes can go both ways and species can either become more complex or more simple based upon their needs. Lamarck was also wrong in the sense that he thought life came about through spontaneous generation and that microbes are new. Both of these suggestions have flaws because life had to come from somewhere and microbes have been around for billions of years, which can be proved through bacteria seen in fossils.
References:
Liu, Y. (2007, September). Like father like son. a fresh review of the inheritance of acquired characteristics. Retrieved February 9, 2021, from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1973965/
Hi Lola,
ReplyDeleteI could not agree more with you that Lamarck's theory of evolution was not entirely different from our current understanding. He claimed a gradual change would occur through species and he extended the idea of change over time, arguing that life started out simple and became perfect. Great post!